In the bloody meadows of Utah: a review of American Primeval

Genre Western

Created & written by Mark L. Smith

Directed by Peter Berg

Starring

Main

Taylor Kitsch as Isaac Reed/Spotted Hawk, a skilled mountain man raised by the Shoshone, haunted by the loss of his wife and son

Betty Gilpin as Sara Holloway/Rowell, Devin’s mother who is a wanted fugitive for the murder and robbery of her wealthy husband, fleeing to take her son to his father in Crooks Springs

Dane DeHaan as Jacob Pratt, a devoted follower of the LDS Church who seeks a better life in Wyoming with his newlywed wife, Abish

Saura Lightfoot-Leon as Abish Pratt, Jacob’s wife and a profound believer in the LDS Church

Derek Hinkey as Red Feather, a Shoshone warrior and leader of the Wolf Clan, who despises white Americans for their aggression against his people

Joe Tippett as James Wolsey, the leader of the Mormon militia

Jai Courtney as Virgil Cutter, a ruthless bounty hunter who leads a group of trappers to find Sara and claim the bounty on her head

Preston Mota as Devin Rowell, Sara’s sensitive young son, who has a physical disability that affects his mobility

Shawnee Pourier as Two Moons, a mute young Indigenous woman who flees her village, seeking refuge with Sara and Devin

Shea Whigham as Jim Bridger, the founder and leader of the Fort Bridger trading post

Recurring

Lucas Neff as Captain Edmund Dellinger, a U.S. Army officer stationed near Fort Bridger

Kyle Davis as Tilly, a combative member of Virgil’s group

Tokala Black Elk as Buffalo Run, a proud warrior of the Wolf Clan

Nick Hargrove as Sammy Cottrell, Bridger’s right-hand man

Dominic Bogart as Frank Cook, a high-ranking member of Mormon militia

Alex Fine as Gant, a loyal member of Virgil’s group

Kip Weeks as Sergeant-Major Pepper, Dellinger’s second-in-command who acts as a spy for the Mormon militia

Andrew P. Logan as Lucas Cutter, Virgil’s younger brother and a local trapper

Kim Coates as Brigham Young, the first governor of the Utah Territory and the second president of the LDS Church

Irene Bedard as Winter Bird, Red Feather’s mother, Reed’s adoptive mother, and the wise matriarch of the Shoshone

Nanabah Grace as Kuttaambo’i, a fierce female warrior of the Wolf Clan

Alex Breaux as Wild Bill Hickman, a high-ranking member of the LDS Church

Jeremiah Bitsui as Grey Fox, a Native American soldier serving under Dellinger

Mosiah Aaron Crowfoot as Young Elk, Red Feather’s son

Theme music composer Explosions In The Sky

Country of origin United States No. of episodes 6

Production

Executive producers Peter Berg, Alexander H. Gayner, Eric Newman, Mark L. Smith

Producers Tim King, Robin Le Chanu

Cinematography Jacques Jouffret

Running time 36–63 minutes

Production companies Grand Electric, Film 44

Original release

Network Netflix Release January 9, 2025

The first thing to know about Netflix’s high-budget 6 part series about the struggle for the territory of Utah is that it is a western in the grimdark genre. It’s hyper-realistic, dark, bloody, violent and with compelling acting and characters. It’s in the same vein as Godless, The English, or Deadwood.

The opening episode has the Mountain Meadow massacre, in which Mormons disguised as natives attack and kill nearly all of a wagon train of settlers – including some fellow Mormons. This is part of an ongoing four sided war, featuring Mormons, settlers, natives, and the US Cavalry.

There aren’t any heroes in this story, but acts of courage abound. Pretty much everyone is morally complex, ranging from Sara, who is taking her young, disabled son to meet his father in Crooks Springs. However, she murdered and robbed her husband back east, and has a large bounty on her head. Brigham Young is leader of the Mormon army and is ruthless, and knew of and perhaps even masterminded the slaughter at Mountain Meadow.

The Pratts are a Mormon couple, the only survivors of the massacre and separated. Badly injured, he winds up back at Fort Bridger, while his wife is taken captive by the Shoshone tribe. The Mormons learn that they survived, and have a deep interest in making sure they don’t stay that way so as to keep their role in the massacre secret.

Some of the characters are very engaging, showing principle and determination, but don’t get too attached. Grimdark, remember?

Netflix pulled out all the stops on this, and the incredible care and precision of the staging shows. Even if the show makes you disquieted, you will admire the sheer stagecraft involved.

Oh, yes, and it is a hell of a good set of stories. Well worth watching.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *